Question for the hobbyists....

sexpanther69

Well-known member
Dec 26, 2013
734
851
93
When reviewing why is it so important to write a penthouse forum type review..... do you guys ask the sp's if their okay with all the details of your encounter.....

Ladies feel free to chime in
 

badbadboy

Well-known member
Nov 2, 2006
9,544
306
83
In Lust Mostly
When reviewing why is it so important to write a penthouse forum type review..... do you guys ask the sp's if their okay with all the details of your encounter.....

Ladies feel free to chime in
I ask for permission first to review because some ladies prefer to not be reviewed.

If they want a review I offer a) not too graphic b) graphic or c) Basic i.e. looks attitude and service.

Some ladies of late said they prefer the erotica as a nice night time read ;)

The interesting aspect of reviewing is found on an international site where the only way you could give a lady an 8 or above was to go 100% Penthouse forum style because their mods demand a graphic representation of the events i.e. blow by blow. If for instance a lady did CBJ only the highest she could get is a 7.
 

voodooking

Banned
Oct 13, 2015
306
1
0
Winnipeg MB
I seen an sp that had read another person's penthouse forum style review about her and she was not impressed with it at all.
The review was way too detailed with every specific detail about what they did and everything she said during the booking.

Personally I don't kiss and tell or divulge all the details of my session with an sp because I respect their privacy.
 

Poonian

Member
Jul 21, 2015
65
8
8
I posted reviews of about 25% of the ladies I see.

Before I do I check here to see if they have explicitly stated they don't want reviews being posted, which I will honor as long as they don't rip me off or anything (which surprisingly hasn't happened to me yet).

The reviews I do post I keep it fairly vague. I don't give a play-by-play but I do cover the pertinent things I think you should know about the SP (i.e. pic vs real, attitude, environment, potential red flags/warnings you should be aware of, limits they may not state in their ads, etc). For me it's more about giving you a realistic "what to expect if you call up this SP" rather than a "here's everything I did".
 

poonmiester

Long Time Member
Jul 11, 2005
906
22
28
I never mention being part of the board ...... if I am happy with the session...I will post a positive review without going into full details ..... and if I am disappointed it will be negative ...... with details that made my session disappointing ......
But I do not ask permission... this is the reason for this board ...it's to be able to express ourselves without having to get approval from anyone..

Otherwise..... what would be the point of having a review board..... ?
 

hornygandalf

Active member
I'm not sure that I've ever explicitly asked a lady if they are okay with a review (maybe I have), but I've also tried to keep the review in line with what others have done. I've never had any lady complain about the review or the amount of detail. I don't give a blow-by-blow description of the whole event (although some of that may be in there), but I do try to recapture the flavour and atmosphere of the time spent.

So, why do I write the kinds of reviews that I do? Several reasons. It is a way to reclaim and rekindle the memories of the event and record them to look back on in the future (assuming it is an event I want to remember). I think it honours the time and effort of the lady I've spent time with. If it wasn't a great experience, I wouldn't write a long detailed narrative.
It is safer to have these accounts tucked away on a site that I can access rather than sitting on my computer where they could be found by someone snooping.
And 'cause, I can :) It is a creative outlet for me. And I hope it entertains, if not inspires, others on the board.
It also feeds my ego to see the complimentary comments that are posted in response, but that is really only a small part of it.

And lastly, because I know that there is a portion of the PERB readership who enjoy the longer reviews or narratives. I do. So, why not cater to that market?
Maybe there should be a new section on PERB for longer literary narratives, and this section only for the brief, checklist type reviews/summaries. The new section would be for longer, more in-depth narratives, and attract a different kind of reader. I noted in the title of my last review that it was a long narrative to discourage those not wanting to read from opening it... and there hasn't (yet) been any complaints about the approach I took.
 

yazoo

New member
Dec 10, 2011
544
0
0
I guess my viewpoint might be a little less knight-in-shining-armour - ish. A review is not a service to the ladies - it's not a reviewers job to promote or damage their business. It is a service to fellow punters. If a lady appreciates a review or doesn't - it is not really that relevant. The relevant thing is that other mongers can decide whether they will get value for their hard-earned dollars when spending it at a certain provider or not.

If someone writes a longer review and it helps someone make a decision then it is a good review. What I don't understand is why people would complain, because someone has taken the time to write.
 

badbadboy

Well-known member
Nov 2, 2006
9,544
306
83
In Lust Mostly
I guess my viewpoint might be a little less knight-in-shining-armour - ish. A review is not a service to the ladies - it's not a reviewers job to promote or damage their business. It is a service to fellow punters. If a lady appreciates a review or doesn't - it is not really that relevant. The relevant thing is that other mongers can decide whether they will get value for their hard-earned dollars when spending it at a certain provider or not.

If someone writes a longer review and it helps someone make a decision then it is a good review. What I don't understand is why people would complain, because someone has taken the time to write.
I hear what you are saying but if there are SP's I like seeing repeatedly and if they prefer no reviews; no review is how it is. I decided a long time ago that this hobby is mine and don't need to share anything if if effects my hobby.

I've posted a lot of reviews here and can say they are the tip of the iceberg. I keep a lot of my activity to myself.

Should I encounter anything that would be detrimental to others then of course I would share it.
 

Feenix

New member
Dec 11, 2006
912
0
0
I am here.
I have seen an estimated 220 women since I started in this hobby. Until relatively recently, I never asked if the lady would like a review. And, I have not reviewed every SP I have seen. I may have reviewed about 50% of them, as a guess

My shortest review was about ten words, my longest quite long with lots of detail. Today I rarely put in all the details, but do comment on something specific that may have happened to make the session memorable to me.

Lately, I have pulled back on writing reviews at all, and have only done so to help a new lady who has few or no reviews, and who I enjoyed my time with. I had an exceptional time with someone this summer that I took the time to make my review a poem.

Only once have I met a provider who has asked for no review, or to never let her name appear anywhere. Actually, I have not yet met her, but have a get together planned for later this week. I have no problem agreeing to her request.
 

Team110

Team110
Nov 12, 2015
38
0
0
I have seen an estimated 220 women since I started in this hobby. Until relatively recently, I never asked if the lady would like a review. And, I have not reviewed every SP I have seen. I may have reviewed about 50% of them, as a guess

My shortest review was about ten words, my longest quite long with lots of detail. Today I rarely put in all the details, but do comment on something specific that may have happened to make the session memorable to me.

Lately, I have pulled back on writing reviews at all, and have only done so to help a new lady who has few or no reviews, and who I enjoyed my time with. I had an exceptional time with someone this summer that I took the time to make my review a poem.

Only once have I met a provider who has asked for no review, or to never let her name appear anywhere. Actually, I have not yet met her, but have a get together planned for later this week. I have no problem agreeing to her request.
I love the idea of a review poem! That would be awesome. Someone start a new thread!
 

PlayfulAlex

Still Playing...
Jan 18, 2010
2,580
0
0
www.playfulAlex.com
When reviewing why is it so important to write a penthouse forum type review..... do you guys ask the sp's if their okay with all the details of your encounter.....

Ladies feel free to chime in
Everyone is different. Some people love to divulge every intimate detail of the encounter, while others like to give up the quick and dirty details. No one said it was *important*; what's important to one person is different than what's important to the next...
 

hornygandalf

Active member
Everyone is different. Some people love to divulge every intimate detail of the encounter, while others like to give up the quick and dirty details. No one said it was *important*; what's important to one person is different than what's important to the next...
Long time since we have heard from you Playful Alex (ahhh yes, there are some memories...). Hope life is treating you well in your retirement from this profession.
 

Elmore

Well-known member
Sep 30, 2011
2,450
1,073
113
North Shore
There are several unique styles that most of us appreciate. Some reviews carry more detail and the only challenge with that is unrealistic expectations that may follow for the next person who sees the lady.
As long as people understand YMMV which is not always about hygiene or how the lady is treated but also about genuine chemistry and attraction then they would realize their session may be very different.

Trying to write a review in a style other than what is natural for you doesn't usually work. I've seen some 5 line bullet point reviews that are great.

At the end of the day some usually end up following a few trusted reviewers with similar taste and expectations to theirs.
The best advice I would offer is...most want to hear a review about the experience...with the overwhelming majority of the emphasis on the lady. Not many of us want to read a review of the pooner.

As such, some will simply describe her as being "very response to oral" rather than "I made her cum like 8 times!"
 

Dickson

Banned
Nov 11, 2011
1,245
2
38
Berlin, Germany
Interesting topic the "Penthouse forum reviews". Do you really want to know? Let start with reviews in general. I have found over the years that reviews are very dangerous. It is a no win situation. I go though a period when I write a lot of reviews. Then after getting attacked by members of a board, persecuted by SPs, being banned from agencies, having SPs refusing to see me, and threatening PMs, I stop. Some members of a board even think because of what I do with SPs it reduces other pooner's chances of getting good service. Really? But ok......

I never review in Europe. I think it is like crapping in you own back yard. Might be easy but it can sure smell up the neighborhood. Making it very unattractive to live there.

I use to review in Toronto but then a recent negative review I wrote blew up in my face and so have so many other reviews in the past. So pulled back there as well. I still think there is a cross on Young street with my name on it with a number of people holding a match. This is especially true when you mess with people's emotions. Ok to fuck someone up the ass and urinate on them is ok but do not ask for emotional simulation. One SP told me that she would rather be called a whore, be fucked hard, and short changed than have to survive a day at the spa, have dinner with me, and be given gifts and do any over night with me. Go figure.

I have learned on Perb it is a no win situation as well. If you do a negative one you get attacked by the white knights and SPs. If you do a good one you can feel the sarcasm in the responses and your reviews are asked to be pulled. As one Perb member pointed out he would not see a SP I saw because of the gushing review I would post. So now I do them more for me. So I do only the good ones that bring back good memories. Sorry it is every man for himself. No one believes what you write anyway so what is the point.

I find it funny a review is like a car accident everyone wants to take a peek but no one wants to own it. It should be the other guy who takes it on the chin. Many SPs hate them as it hurts their business once they are established. They say they are not "kiss and tell" ladies. Only at the beginning when ladies are attempting to get established do reviews serve a purpose. Many established ladies have a "no review policy". Her regulars do not want to know what she does with other clients. It makes them feel, well "less special".

I recently did a bunch for the memories and did not realize that good reviews can be so damaging for a SPs. Sharing our experience was a problem as her other high end clients read them and those clients were hurt as it took away from there experience with her. Her clients kept asking the SP why don't you do that with me. So I had them removed. I do not write them to hurt any one. It is to recall positive memories and to make my experience more enjoyable.

On the style. I use to write the short versions. But as the objective changed so did my style. Moving from the L, A, B, S type to the so call "Penthouse style" allows me to relive the moment in the style I like. You need to ask the SP what she likes. Most do not like them, especially if it hurts her client's Impression of her. High end ladies do not like them at all. Not good for business. Even wonder why the best SPs have few reviews. Those starting out need them but the high end ladies live off referrals outside Reviews. One SP told me many of the high end clients would never see a lady on PERB. Interesting. The high end clients seek other ladies, lower volume, exclusive ladies. High end clients to not want to know what she does with others, only what she will do for him. Who wants other guys seconds? You want to stick your face where a guy just blew his load?

On prior approval of reviews. Yes, in most cases I have the SP review it and comment on her take of the event. Now I am asking the SP to give me her take on the night and I like to compare our vision of the night. All Off line of course. What was her take on what happened? It makes it so much more enjoyable for me to feel special.

Since most of my dates are dinner dates and over nights and involve some type of event. I have much more to recall than a one hour or two hour roll in bed. Mine tend to require more planning and a number of elements. Recently just did one where I had the SP spend the day at the spa. Then had her come to me in a limo service. Brought her up to the penthouse suite to be met by two guitar players and singers. Had the room decorated with a Christmas tree, candles, in a holiday theme. Then had dinner served, by our own private waiter, in the room we were the serenading took place. A little private dancing. Which turned into a karaoke event, her singing with the guys. This was followed by a two hour special visit by a SP that my SP wanted to see for her total pleasure. Followed by an over night for the two of us. Not sure I can do it justice in a few paragraphs. Does not matter as I would not review her again, too much trouble for her, her clients, and me. Many of the PERB members dislike my reviews so what is the point. They provide no value for those members. As one member put it. "Just the Facts" "just the facts". Does she dfk and bbbj? Besides they can not relate to my events as they are totally foreign to many who are interest in just a half hour, one or two hour date. Now I just review for my own pleasure. Maybe I am getting too old for this.

I have had a SP review my review and approve it. Then I was asked to remove it and or change it once it was posted. Her other clients did not like it. I think the one that stung the most was when she ask me to take it off because it was too explicit. Then when I did she posted one that was as explicit as what I wrote. To add to that others were as explicit as mine. There are other elements that were coming to play. But the review was the symptom not the disease.

I normally do not keeps lists or keep notes on the SPs I have seen over the years. I do remember special moments with those special ladies I have had the pleasure of seeing. I wonder if they remember me. But it is like the wind on a hot Spanish night. It comes and goes. If you wait there will another one to follow. Each as beautify as the last. But in that moment it feels so good! Don't get attached as it will be gone as soon as you blink an eye. Don't feel bad another one will be by in a heart beat.

Over all reviews are not a good thing. You are damned if you do and damned if you don't. But that is just my opinion and I have learned my opinion does not mean much any more.

But I could not resist this topic.
 

hornygandalf

Active member
And welcome back to the board Dickson.
Merry Christmas, and remember that some do appreciate reading the recollections you post for yourself.

Interesting take on reviews taking away from the experiences of others... Or the illusion of their relationship in that moment in time. I'm not you, but I do wonder if you are too hard on yourself in some of what you have written... But, those are your experiences...
 

Dickson

Banned
Nov 11, 2011
1,245
2
38
Berlin, Germany
And welcome back to the board Dickson.
Merry Christmas, and remember that some do appreciate reading the recollections you post for yourself.

Interesting take on reviews taking away from the experiences of others... Or the illusion of their relationship in that moment in time. I'm not you, but I do wonder if you are too hard on yourself in some of what you have written... But, those are your experiences...
Not hard on my self just reflecting the reality of what I receive from others. Once things start to pile up from multiple posters and multiple SPs there becomes a pattern. That pattern has been based on a life time of experiences. Not complaining. It is like gravity it is just who I am and I come to expected. It is life my friend.

I just had a SP who normally charges $250. Hit me with a charge of $350 an hour to have dinner with her. It is Dickson screw him to the wall mentality. To be expected. That is why guys like me can never have a relationship and a guys like me can never have friends. Everyone just wants to suck you dry. They are a friend or a client as long as they can suck you dry. Once some one better comes along rates go up and they do not have time. I have no redeeming qualities other than the dollars I throw around. Be honest you would not had dinner with me if I was not buying you dinner and bringing Catherine along? Why would you? Does it matter? Not really. It is life my friend. I am use to it. I pay people to get what I want. They do what I pay them to do.nothing more nothing less.

Not a bad life it just is. You my friend know if people want to be friends with you they do it not for what you have but for who you are. You are a lucky guy. I often wish I could have what you have. I always say be careful what you wish for.
 
Vancouver Escorts