If really getting into the details smaller or medium breasts, natural or not noticable lip filler, less tattoos, I like that girl next door, barista, college look
Darla has been mentioned and I'd second that. She's petite.. phenomenal ass. It's been some time since I've seen her but she was a lot of fun. Not sure of she fits your girl next door look though.
Lucy Luxe gas also been mentioned. She's slim, beautiful and petite.
Olivia Hartley might fit your description. Naturally beautiful. Infectious smile and genuine service. She will put you at ease immediately.
Islands finest has a plethora of young spinner esq women that may catch your eye. They have a different cost system than other agencies but they will sort you out.
Riley from SweetVips is someone I gel with quite well. I've seen her several times. Blonde, petite, natural and Beautiful. More of a surfer girl vibe than barista. I quite like her.
One wild card ill throw out is Samantha Hensyn. I wouldn't call her your typical Girl next door but she oozes sex appeal to me. I only saw her for a massage (which was unreal) but I really want to see her for more. She's slim, quirky, funny, petite and toned. She is a bit more of a free spirit Naturally beauty rather than girl next door type though
Cheers