I find these threads crazy because aren't they just phones with similar specs?
If one does everything you want for your personal life and or biz; isn't that what counts?
I chose Apple because of the iCloud and it's ease of integration across multiple platforms.
I didn't trust Google because everything is wide open with their browser and all it's plugins.
SP's who use gmail should ensure all their personal data is not exposed via Google. I had one SP respond to me and it had all her personal info wide open to view.
Having said that, the phones from Android and Apple are all good devices. It's what they do for you personally.